KEN KIRSCHENBAUM, ESQ
ALARM - SECURITY INDUSTRY LEGAL EMAIL NEWSLETTER / THE ALARM EXCHANGE
You can read all of our articles on our website. Having trouble getting our emails? Change your spam controls and whitelist firstname.lastname@example.org
Virtual doorman and remote gate monitoring and access contract present new opportunity
August 25, 2023
Virtual doorman and remote gate monitoring and access contract present new opportunity
I don’t know if we are witnessing the kind of technological evolution we had when digital dialers replaced the telephone dialer, or when glass breakers and motion replaced foil [if that was how foil bit the dust], but the merging of audio / video with access control is certainly making in-roads with physical security. I am referring to a building doorman and security guards at ingress points manning a community gate and even roving guards touring outdoor sites or buildings. I suppose like robots are replacing workers in some industries the electronic industry has caught up with the physical guard industry.
Peter Giacalone has been around a long time and is a well-known security consultant and fellow columnist at Security Sales and Integration magazine. Peter sent out a newsletter on July 31, 2023 that I have copied below wherein he discusses the changes in the guard and monitoring industry. I know about these changes because alarm clients needed new contracts to be created to cover their new services. While the technology may not have been new, its application to the new service is relatively new. And sure, I suppose there are some alarm companies out there who have been offering these services for a few years now, but what we are seeing, and will see, is mainstream alarm companies offering these services, virtual doorman and virtual remote gate monitoring and access control services. This will be a boon to the alarm dealer and the central stations offering to provide the monitoring.
How does it work? Well, pretty much just like the name of the contract suggests.
Virtual doorman: Instead of having a doorman or guard at the building entrance the alarm company installs cameras, two-way audio, and can remotely open the access controlled doors. This service can be expanded to offer supervised access by guests or even residents by increased surveillance throughout the building. While this service is by no means cheap, it’s cheaper than live guards.
Virtual Remote Gate Guard Monitoring and Access Control Service: Manned guards at the community gate will be a luxury of the past. Welcome to a guard booth that houses cameras, two-way audio and access control that when activated will raise the vehicle gate. Cameras can follow a vehicle throughout the community if that’s what the community wants. This is even more expensive because of the anticipated increased activity. Egris is typically not monitored, though it is video recorded.
Either of the above contracts can be used for roving guards at a construction site or within a building.
Yes, you need a contract and yes K&K has one [or both] for you.
VIRTUAL REMOTE GATE GUARD MONITORING AND ACCESS CONTROL SERVICE: Sale [also comes in lease]
Here is Peter’s article:
How the Guarding & Monitoring Industry Is Changing Forever by Peter P. Giacalone July 31, 2023
The phrase “remote video guarding” is a technology mix that brings two separate industries together. The first part, remote video, refers to the monitoring industry and its increasing emphasis on using remote video to verify alarm intrusions. The second part, of course, refers to the guarding industry — the centuries-old practice of hiring human beings to protect life and property.
Remote video guarding is not just a phrase that merges two industries. It’s also a capability that is rapidly transforming and disrupting both industries at once, and it has just as much to do with the evolution of technology as the changing demographics of American society. America is walking into a demographic crisis. We are still far better off than our friends in Europe and East Asia, but we’re not worried about them, we’re worried about us.
We have a demographic crisis because our population is aging and our birth rates are rapidly declining. As recently as 2007, the U.S. fertility rate was still at 2.12, slightly above replacement level, but as of 2022, we’re down to 1.7 births per woman.
Impact of Remote Video Guarding on Guarding
The implications for the physical security industry are quite apparent. Security guarding is a relatively low-paying job typically staffed by younger people at the start of their careers. Now, not only are there fewer, young, able-bodied people to go around, they also increasingly don’t want to be security guards, given the availability of higher-paying, more comfortable alternatives that don’t involve the prospect of having to potentially confront an armed robber or active shooter.
Because of this demographic challenge, guarding executives are at their wits’ end looking for solutions. They are facing compressed margins due to rising labor costs and customers who aren’t willing to pay more, and these are leading to challenges in keeping a guard force fully staffed.
To meet this need, an industry has begun emerging known as “remote guarding.” It’s like an Uber and ChatGPT fusion for the guarding industry. The idea is that security cameras mounted with AI can automatically detect probable threats and send an alert to a security operations center (SOC). The SOC operator will then validate the threat and either notify first responders or dispatch human security guards.
Now, instead of having a guard simply man a post and walk some predictable patrol route where nothing might happen, each camera deployment serves as “eyes” that protect life and property, allowing human operators and guards to respond to threats in real time.
The guarding industry, though, is understandably reluctant to fully embrace this technology. Many senior executives are concerned that remote guarding will cannibalize their existing guarding revenues, and they are not necessarily wrong. Consider the variables in the following chart:
All revenue dollars are not created equal. Remote guarding is both significantly higher margin and higher growth than traditional guarding. There’s a reason why Tesla is worth $550 billion at $80 billion revenues while Walmart is “only” worth $400 billion at over $600 billion in annual revenues. Gross margins and growth are a much greater contributor to shareholder value than a high volume of low margin revenues.
Impact of Remote Video Guarding on Monitoring
Along with the challenges mentioned that are problematic for the guard industry, the monitoring industry is facing similar existential headwinds as well: low margins, low growth and high churn. Much of this is caused by the workforce challenges along with rising hourly pay rates. Because of these headwinds, monitoring has increasingly become an industry that resembles what economists call “perfect competition,” where services are so commoditized and competition is so numerous that long-term profitability asymptotes toward zero.
While remote video monitoring has existed for a few years now, compared to traditional alarm monitoring, it is a relatively new frontier.
The antidote for this is remote video monitoring! Remote video monitoring is akin to live content streaming in an era where everyone else is still competing on how many VHSs and DVDs they rent.
The big advantage that incumbent monitoring centers already have is the infrastructure, processes and personnel in place that can be much more easily pivoted toward video monitoring than a company that’s building such a capability from scratch.
However, even with these advantages, market share in remote video monitoring is being rapidly gobbled up by companies that are building from scratch rather than monitoring companies making a pivot with all of their inherent advantages. That’s why the dominant players in video monitoring are the likes of Stealth Monitoring, EyeQ Monitoring and Eyeforce, instead of traditional full-service and third-party monitoring centers.
Fortunately, most monitoring company executives recognize this trend and have begun looking into an expansion, if not a transition into remote guarding. Yet their execution velocity has left a lot to be desired. It seems like most monitoring companies are letting “perfect be the enemy of the good” and are bogged down by inaction while the “pure-play video” actors take more and more market share.
While remote video monitoring has existed for a few years now, compared to traditional alarm monitoring, it is a relatively new frontier. It is a blue ocean market where dealers selling video monitoring are more likely to come up against non-consumption or manned guarding as an alternative than other video monitoring providers.
Haves & the Have Nots
This new frontier is going to create winners and losers in both monitoring and guarding. In fact, the two industries will increasingly converge to compete with each other. For example, it has become apparent that a select few of the large full-service and third-party centers are building remote guarding capability.
Companies who are willing to act decisively, make mistakes and learn from them will take the lion’s share of the market. Those who end up stuck in their ways will be caught between a rock and hard place — the no man’s land between a stagnating, low margin and high churn business, and an inability to gain traction in video.
Peter P. Giacalone is a security professional for 40 years, is president of Giacalone Associates LLC, an independent security consulting firm serving central stations, manufacturers, and dealers throughout the world. He can be contacted at (201) 394-5536 or email@example.com.
STANDARD FORM AGREEMENTS: To order up to date Standard Form Alarm / Security / Fire and related Agreements click here: www.alarmcontracts.com
CONCIERGE LAWYER SERVICE PROGRAM FOR THE ALARM INDUSTRY - You can check out the program and sign up here: https://www.kirschenbaumesq.com/page/concierge or contact our Program Coordinator Stacy Spector, Esq at 516 747 6700 x 304.
ALARM ARTICLES: You can always read our Articles on our website at www.kirschenbaumesq.com/page/alarm-articles updated daily *************************
THE ALARM EXCHANGE - the alarm industries leading classified and business exchange - updated daily.
Wondering how much your alarm company is worth?
Click here: https://www.kirschenbaumesq.com/page/what-is-my-alarm-company-worth
Getting on our email list / Articles archived:
Many of you are forwarding these emails to friends or asking that others be added to the list. Sign up for our daily newsletter here: Sign Up.
Kirschenbaum & Kirschenbaum PC
Attorneys at Law
200 Garden City Plaza
Garden City, NY 11530
516 747 6700 x 301