KIRSCHENBAUM & KIRSCHENBAUM, P.C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW
200 Garden City Plaza
Garden City, New York 11530
516-747-6700
![]()
Q&A - New Home Owners who don't sign contract - what to do
Question:
Want to ask you about something that has been on my mind for quite some
time. If we have installed a security system for a homeowner and we have them
under contract (using your monitoring contract) and the homeowner notifies us
they are moving. We attempt to sign up the new owner but some times we are
not successful. We have de-programmed the communicator so the system is no
longer monitored. What is our liability regarding the new owner since we never
contracted with them. What if they use the alarm locally and it fails, do we
have any liability? Should we disable the alarm totally instead of just disabl
ing the communicator?
Thank you!!
Mark Rosa
Director of Service
Business Electronics Inc.
Answer:
For purposes of this answer I assume that you have a Sales contract with
your subscriber, the former home owners, as well as the Monitoring contract
that you mention. You should also have a Service contract.
The Sales contract covers only the installation and the warranty work; no
recurring revenue is found in the Sales contract. The Monitoring contract is
terminable by you in the event of the subscriber's default in payment. The
Monitoring contract is also not assignable by the subscribe without your
permission. In your case your subscriber has no doubt defaulted and remains liable
for the balance of the contract. You could have also placed a lien against
the security equipment if you have the UCC clause in your monitoring contract.
But let's assume that the balance owed in not significant and you don't want
to pursue the subscriber. What duty do you owe the new owner? None, unless
you do something that could be construed by the new owner that you are
continuing the alarm monitoring service.
Once you learn of the new owner you must terminate service immediately
and unequivocally. The monitoring should be shut down and no service provided.
The new owner needs to be treated as a new prospective subscriber, and you
should not be providing any monitoring or service to a prospective subscriber
until your contracts are signed and that prospective subscriber becomes a
subscriber. Your notice to a new owner that your service in not being provided can
be by mail or telephone, which should be recorded. Certified mail is not
necessary.
You have no right to "totally disarm" the alarm system. I am assuming
that your subscriber purchased the equipment. You are only providing
monitoring, and you lease the communication device, and your contract permits you to
terminate the monitoring service. If you have an updated Monitoring contract it
also provides that you will release the code or password only upon completion
of the monitoring contract, so absent some local law requiring you to release
that code, you don't have to, but the local system is not yours and you have
no reason to disarm it.
Here is another idea. I don't see why you can't program a message on the
control panel stating that no monitoring is being provided. That message
could be programed for a short while. I don't suggest other messages that may
contain other words that may be offensive.
![]()